2009 AAY - Pony 2nd Go
| Draw | Contestant | City | ST | Pony | 1Go Time | 2Go Time | 2Go PL |
| 38 | Bailey Sheppard | Brandon | ms | Bucket | 14.396 | 14.989 | 1D 1st |
| 33 | Cierra Chapman | Kiowa | ia | Gunsmoke | 499.000 | 15.155 | 1D 2nd |
| 55 | Brandi Pittman | Bogalusa | la | T Joe | 15.348 | 15.203 | 1D 3rd |
| 60 | Jaci Lee Montgomery | Brookhaven | ms | Gambling Chance | 15.507 | 15.235 | 1D 4th |
| 7 | Wyatt Cingolani | Lake Village | ar | Redbud | 15.412 | 15.305 | |
| 12 | Breanna Johnson | Wiggins | ms | Blacky | 15.479 | 15.408 | |
| 50 | Laken Koestler | Vicksburg | ms | Shades | 15.425 | 15.584 | |
| 4 | Audrey Claire Henderson | Kisciousko | ms | Little Red | 16.606 | 15.609 | |
| 44 | Adyson Mann | Kosciusko | ms | Cotton Candy | 15.686 | 15.625 | |
| 48 | Kizer Hensley | Brentwood | tn | Sheza Goldin Nugget | 15.878 | 15.699 | |
| 27 | Austin Wiggins | Ashburn | ga | Silver Britches | 16.130 | 15.714 | |
| 34 | Savannah Henry | Springville | al | Shotgun Red | 15.361 | 15.715 | |
| 40 | Natalie Brady | Pelahatchie | ms | Cowgirl | 15.349 | 15.720 | |
| 39 | Audrey Claire Henderson | Kosciusko | ms | Katie Sue | 15.935 | 15.721 | |
| 22 | Audrey Claire Henderson | Kosciusko | Cash | 16.022 | 15.864 | ||
| 23 | Reagan Long | Jonesboro | ar | Foxy | 499.000 | 15.916 | |
| 28 | Brandi Pittman | Bogalusa | la | Root Beer | 15.786 | 15.919 | |
| 52 | Anna Vincent | Brandon | ms | Lucky | 15.929 | 15.926 | |
| 42 | Brittannie Johnson | Wiggins | ms | Buck | 15.706 | 15.944 | |
| 5 | Hunter Davis | Lucedale | ms | Sugar | 15.925 | 15.948 | |
| 15 | Molly Wall | Jonesboro | ar | Spanky Little Rascal | 15.700 | 15.998 | 2D 1st |
| 35 | Catherine Ladner | Gulfport | ms | Pepper | 216.283 | 16.009 | 2D 2nd |
| 36 | Rebecca Hagan | Centreville | ms | Pokey | 16.136 | 16.095 | 2D 3rd |
| 32 | Makenzie Richardson | Brookhaven | ms | Buddy | 15.552 | 16.117 | 2D 4th |
| 53 | Audrey Claire Henderson | Kosciusko | ms | Twister | 17.482 | 16.236 | |
| 25 | Wyatt Cingolani | Lake Village | ar | Magic | 16.831 | 16.274 | |
| 6 | Brooke Hazel | Eastaboga | al | Rusty | 18.025 | 16.350 | |
| 31 | Jax Johnson | Jonesboro | ar | Sam | 16.347 | 16.433 | |
| 24 | Anna Vincent | Brandon | ms | Buckshot | 16.807 | 16.535 | |
| 18 | Codeyn Scarbrough | Lucedale | ms | Bro | 17.431 | 16.571 | |
| 57 | TyTy McLoud | Deer Park | al | Dunny | 16.505 | 16.603 | |
| 47 | Brittany Graham | Brandon | ms | Lily | 16.854 | 16.629 | |
| 49 | Allison Harris | Ashville | al | Angel | 17.137 | 16.672 | |
| 54 | Skylar Glenn | Meridian | ms | Prissy | 116.620 | 16.688 | |
| 14 | Madison Overby | Collinsville | ms | Scout | 16.549 | 16.697 | |
| 10 | Julie Hill | Cabot | ar | Sassy | 17.097 | 16.717 | |
| 46 | Trey Cloud | Lyons | ga | Turbo | 17.387 | 16.764 | |
| 45 | Kamry Bond | Lumberton | ms | Trigger | 16.278 | 16.892 | |
| 3 | Coltyn Scarbrough | Lucedale | ms | Red Bean | 17.488 | 16.983 | |
| 1 | Bayleigh Choate | Cleveland | tn | DJ | 18.449 | 17.382 | 3D 1st |
| 19 | Trey Cloud | Lyons | ga | Little Buck | 17.539 | 17.536 | 3D 2nd |
| 30 | Angelique Sellers | Youngsville | la | Libby | 18.140 | 17.697 | 3D 3rd |
| 16 | Bailey Jo LeBlanc | Houma | la | Chip | 18.486 | 17.721 | 3D 4th |
| 20 | Destin Beck | Albertville | al | Red | 17.261 | 17.831 | |
| 56 | Emma Grace Roberts | Lucedale | ms | Crissy | 18.100 | 17.846 | |
| 41 | Todd Bracey Calcote | Brookhavean | ms | Smoky Joe | 17.597 | 17.876 | |
| 26 | Annabelle Graham | Brandon | ms | Tank | 499.000 | 17.954 | |
| 9 | Skylar Glenn | Meridian | ms | Star | 16.754 | 18.003 | |
| 43 | Dakota Wells | Summit | ms | Tater Tot | 17.224 | 18.347 | |
| 59 | Tanner Odom | Lucedale | ms | Mr. Jess Lightning | 19.477 | 19.031 | |
| 58 | Dallas Wiggins | Ashburn | ga | Shorty | 18.871 | 19.114 | |
| 29 | Peytin McKay | Kiln | ms | Fancy | 19.154 | 20.476 | |
| 11 | Victoria Martin | Meridian | ms | Cracker Jack | 15.825 | 116.792 | |
| 13 | Taylor Duncan | Lake | ms | Party Girl | 18.844 | 117.282 | |
| 61 | Emily Jo Gentry | Armorel | ar | Peanut | 16.230 | 120.968 | |
| 17 | Haleigh McNeil | Enterprise | ms | Honey | 15.851 | 499.000 | |
| 2 | Will Huter | Gurley | al | Marshall | 16.826 | 499.000 | |
| 37 | McKayla Ferrell | Creal Springs | il | Toby | 18.515 | 499.000 | |
| 8 | Morgan Baker | Perkinston | ms | Popcorn | 19.606 | 499.000 | |
| 51 | Miranda Frith | Grove Hill | al | Magic | 499.000 | 499.000 | |
| 21 | Kizer Hensley | Brentwood | tn | Dunny | 499.000 | 500.000 |
